Home » Civil Service India Poll » Poll Comments
Union Minister of State for Minority Affairs Mukhtar Abbas Naqvi, asked beef eaters to go to Pakistan. Should he be penalised for making such a statement? Is the BJP stand justified on cow slaughter?
  A law is a must to protect the sentiments of Hindus 24.97 % (783)
  Muslim sentiments and customs should be allowed to be practised 21.84 % (685)
  A law banning cow slaughter need not be passed 20.18 % (633)
  BJP is forcing its agenda on the people
14.48 % (454)
  Minister was wrong, but BJP stand is right
10.97 % (344)
  I don't care, there are other issues that need urgent attention 7.56 % (237)
Total votes: 3136

Send comment
Version 2.04
P.Indrani - 26/08/2015 05:11
-
Indians are more pantriotic.
some of the people give their lives for the country. we want to respect them. take inspiring from those peolples.
 
surender - 10/07/2015 14:54
-
why just ban beef why not other animals?what about those people whose livelihood is based on these beef ?why to relate beef eaters to pakistan ?whether he want to indirectly indicate that all who eat beef are muslims?
these are some of the critical question which bjp must answer.
obviously he made a wrong comment .his comment is just politically(not religiously) motivated.
he just want to show that bjp is trying to save rights & culture of hindus. due to all these comments by few bjp ministers like him,uma bharti the image of bjp is definitely affected.nowdays some people's religious sentiment is easily getting hurt,they are opposing movies like pk,bajrangibhaijan but the same people were not affected during o my god(OMG) movie.even tthe actor parash rawel is a MP from no other than bjp.such minister must understand that they must leave religious politics and try to give their view based on logic and not just rhetoric
people want real development not your slogans,promises.
 
NUR NAZIBUR RAHMAN - 30/06/2015 05:52
-
YES HE SHOULD BE PENALISED. BECAUSE IF A MINISTES SAYS SO TO BUTTER THE MAJORITY HINDU FLAVOURED PEOPLE WHAT THE GOVERNMENT EXPECTS FROM US. WE THE PEOPLE OF NORTHEAST ARE DEPRIVED FROM EVERY ASPECTS .BEEF IS CONSUMED BY MOST OF THE TRIBES OF NORT-EAST. SO DEAR MINISTER YOU SHOULD COMMENT KNOWING THE FACTS. ONLY GIVING CHEAP TALKS DOES NOT MAKE YOU GREAT.
 
Tanumoy Mondal - 30/06/2015 05:04
-
every day slaughtering thousands of cows should be banned, it is inhuman. but according to the Quran it is mandatory for the muslims to have beef. so i think a law should be passed to legalize having beef only on such occasions. and create alternative employment for those engaged in cow slaughtering business as India has enough resources to be utilized properly.
 
Alam parvej - 29/06/2015 07:19
-
Our national animal eats cow- komatha. Does it matter he is animal. After all he eats ur komatha. How could an animal be given such honour whil it hurts religious sentiment? Spit on u u dogs of bjp. N mr anuj kumar think well before humiliating a religious figure. I can abuse ur mother cause she gave birth such a spitful jerk like u. Spit on ur existence. Spit on ufor making such an shameful comment. U coservativr simpleton.
 

View Previous Polls